Frequently Asked Investigation Process Questions
Getting Started
Making a report lets OCR know about possible discrimination, harassment, or sexual misconduct. A report does not automatically mean that a formal investigation will happen.
After receiving a report, OCR generally contacts the person who may have experienced the conduct to provide information about available resources, supportive measures, and possible ways the University can respond.
A complaint is a request for the University to investigate alleged prohibited conduct and determine whether University policy was violated.
In some circumstances, the University may determine that it needs to investigate even if the person who made or is affected by the report does not want an investigation.
OCR conducts an initial review of the information that has been reported. Among other things, OCR considers:
- whether the reported conduct could violate University policy if the allegations are substantiated;
- which University policy or policies apply;
- whether OCR has enough information to move forward;
- the wishes of the person who may have experienced the conduct; and
- what type of University response may be appropriate.
Depending on the circumstances, possible responses may include closing the matter, an educational response, an administrative review, alternative resolution, or a formal investigation.
For allegations that may constitute Title IX Sexual Harassment, OCR also determines whether the allegations meet the requirements for proceeding under the Title IX policy.
When OCR opens a formal investigation, the parties receive written notice. The notice provides enough information about the allegations to allow the parties to understand what is being investigated and prepare for their interviews.
The notice generally identifies:
- the parties, if known;
- the conduct that is alleged to have occurred;
- the policy provisions that may apply; and
- the date and location of the alleged conduct, if known.
If additional allegations are added to the investigation later, OCR will provide the parties with notice of those allegations.
No. An investigation is the process OCR uses to gather and evaluate information. A decision that allegations should be investigated is not a determination that a policy violation occurred.
The respondent is presumed not responsible for the alleged conduct unless and until responsibility is established through the complaint resolution process.
Similarly, the fact that an investigation does not ultimately result in a finding of a policy violation does not necessarily mean that a complaint was made in bad faith.
During the Investigation
One or more trained investigators will conduct the investigation. Investigators are generally members of OCR who are Civil Rights and Title IX Compliance Specialists; however, OCR may hire an external investigator to conduct the investigation.
The investigator’s job is to gather and objectively evaluate relevant information. For investigations under the Policy on Discrimination, Harassment, and Sexual Misconduct, the investigator will make a determination as to whether the policy has been violated. The investigator does not serve as an advocate for either party.
The investigator gathers information that is relevant to determine what happened and whether University policy was violated.
Depending on the case, this may include:
- interviewing the complainant and respondent;
- interviewing witnesses;
- reviewing emails, text messages, photographs, videos, documents, social media, or other electronic information;
- reviewing relevant University records;
- asking parties or witnesses follow-up questions; and
- seeking other information that may help the investigator understand the allegations.
The University has the responsibility for conducting the investigation. A party does not have to investigate the case on their own.
Typically, yes, if you are a complainant or respondent participating in the investigation. However, the parties and witnesses are not required to participate in the investigation.
The investigator will generally meet separately with the complainant and respondent. The investigator may also interview witnesses who have relevant information.
There may be more than one interview. An investigator may contact a party or witness again if additional information raises follow-up questions.
The investigator will explain the process and ask questions about information relevant to the investigation.
The interview is an opportunity for you to explain what happened from your perspective. You should answer questions as completely and accurately as you can. It is also okay to say that you do not remember something or do not know the answer to a question.
You may also identify relevant documents, communications, witnesses, or other information that you think the investigator should consider.
Participation in an investigation is voluntary and you are not required to participate. OCR does not draw a negative conclusion simply because a party or witness chooses not to participate.
However, choosing not to participate may limit the information available to the investigator. The University may also continue an investigation and make decisions based on the information that is available even if a party chooses not to participate.
Yes. A person may decide to participate in some parts of an investigation and not others.
It is important to understand, however, that limiting participation can affect the information available to the investigator. For example, if a party does not respond to questions about information provided by another participant, the investigator may need to evaluate that information without the benefit of the party’s response.
You can speak with OCR if you have questions about participating.
Yes. A complainant or respondent may have an advisor during the investigation.
An advisor can be a friend, family member, attorney, union representative where applicable, or another person who you would like to support you during the investigation. The only restriction is for investigations under the Policy on Discrimination, Harassment, and Sexual Misconduct the advisor cannot be a party or witness in the investigation.
During the investigation, the advisor’s primary role is to support the party. The party, rather than the advisor, answers the investigator’s questions and provides information. An advisor may not answer questions, submit information, or otherwise participate in place of the party.
If you would like to identify an advisor, please complete the form linked below to include the name and contact information for your advisor. This form will grant our office with your written consent to copy your advisor on all communications with our office and invitations to meet with OCR:
Yes. OCR can work with participants who need reasonable accommodations related to a disability and can address other accessibility needs, including translation or language-access needs.
If you believe you need an accommodation to participate fully in the process, contact OCR as early as possible.
The investigator will ask each party and witness if they give permission to record and transcribe the interview. If a party or witness does not agree to be recorded, then the investigator will prepare a statement of the interview and the party or witness who declined to be recorded will have the opportunity to review the interview statement. Participants may not make their own recording of an investigation meeting unless OCR has expressly authorized it.
Yes. You may use notes to help you remember dates, events, or topics you want to discuss.
Your interview is also an opportunity to provide relevant documents or other information to the investigator. You do not need to remember every detail or locate every document before your first interview. The investigator may allow additional information to be submitted as the investigation continues, subject to the deadlines in the applicable process.
You may provide information that you believe is relevant to the allegations. Depending on the circumstances, this might include:
- emails or text messages;
- photographs or videos;
- screenshots;
- social media communications;
- calendars;
- relevant documents or records;
- names of people who may have relevant information; or
- other information that helps explain what happened.
The investigator determines what information is relevant to the investigation and may ask questions about evidence you submit.
That does not prevent you from participating in an investigation. Information provided by the parties and witnesses is evidence and will be considered along with other relevant information available in the case. The investigator considers the information as a whole rather than requiring a particular type of evidence.
Yes. Both the complainant and respondent may identify people they believe have relevant information. It is helpful to explain what you believe each person may know. The investigator determines which witnesses to interview and may decide not to interview a proposed witness if, for example, the person does not appear to have relevant information or their information would simply repeat information the investigator already has. The investigator may also interview people who were not identified by either party.
Yes. Parties may suggest questions or topics they believe should be addressed with another party or a witness. The investigator will consider the request but determines which questions are relevant and appropriate to ask.
Contact the investigator as soon as possible. Investigations often develop over time, and participants may remember additional details or locate additional information after an interview. The investigator can tell you whether and how to submit the additional information. You should try to provide information before the investigation closes and within any deadlines given to you.
An investigation sometimes identifies information that was not included in the original notice. OCR will determine whether the new information should be included in the investigation, addressed separately, referred to another University office, or handled in another way.
If OCR decides to investigate additional allegations involving a complainant or respondent, the parties will receive written notice of the additional allegations.
Privacy and Communication
OCR treats reports and investigations as private matters and shares personally identifiable information only as appropriate to investigate and respond to a report, provide support, or meet University obligations.
For OCR to conduct a fair investigation, the investigator may need to share allegations, evidence, and identifying information with the parties and others involved in the process. Witness identities are typically shared with the parties during the investigation process.
The University encourages participants to respect the privacy of the investigation. Parties, witnesses, and investigators will be asked to keep the information related to the investigation and resolution private, to the extent consistent with applicable law.
At the same time, parties are not categorically prohibited from discussing their experience or the allegations. For example, a party may need to talk with an advisor, attorney, family member, support person, health care provider, or another person who can provide assistance.
Participants should be careful not to communicate in a way that interferes with the investigation, intimidates or pressures another participant, or could constitute retaliation.
Retaliation generally involves taking action against someone because they reported possible discrimination, harassment, or sexual misconduct or participated in an investigation or related process.
Retaliation is prohibited.
If you are concerned that you or someone else may be experiencing retaliation connected to a report or investigation, contact OCR promptly. A retaliation concern can be addressed even if the original investigation has not concluded and regardless of the ultimate outcome of the underlying complaint.
Support During an Investigation
Yes. Supportive measures are available to complainants and respondents before, during, and after an investigation.
Depending on the circumstances, supportive measures may include:
- assistance accessing counseling resources;
- academic adjustments;
- modifications to work or class schedules;
- changes in housing or work locations;
- no-contact directives or other restrictions on contact;
- leaves of absence;
- campus safety measures; or
- other individualized assistance.
Supportive measures are intended to help preserve access to Northwestern’s programs and activities and are not a finding that anyone violated University policy.
Contact OCR. Supportive measures can be reconsidered as circumstances change. You do not need to wait until the investigation is completed to raise a new concern or request that an existing measure be reviewed.
The University’s process is separate from a criminal investigation or civil court proceeding. A person may report conduct to law enforcement and also participate in Northwestern’s process. In some circumstances, OCR may temporarily pause certain investigative steps so that law enforcement can gather evidence. Generally, however, Northwestern may proceed with its own investigation even if a law-enforcement investigation is occurring at the same time.
The legal standards and procedures used by courts and law enforcement are different from Northwestern’s policy process.
Timing
The time needed depends on the circumstances of the particular case.
OCR strives to complete an investigation within 90 business days after the written notice of investigation is sent. That period may be extended for good cause. There are a number of factors that can affect the timeline including:
- the number of allegations;
- the number and availability of witnesses;
- the amount or complexity of the evidence;
- academic breaks or leaves of absence;
- the need for additional investigative steps;
- newly received information;
- concurrent law-enforcement activity; and
- other unexpected circumstances.
An investigation may develop as additional information is obtained. The investigator may need to interview additional witnesses, review new documents, conduct follow-up interviews, or give a party an opportunity to respond to newly received information.
The goal is to complete investigations promptly while providing a fair opportunity for both parties to provide information and respond to relevant evidence. In addition, the Title IX regulations provide specific timeframes for certain steps of an investigation.
Reviewing the Evidence and Investigation Report
Yes. Both policies provide the parties an opportunity to review relevant information gathered during the investigation and provide a response before the applicable decision-making process is completed.
The specific procedures and deadlines differ under the two policies. OCR will give the parties instructions explaining what materials are available for review, how they may be accessed, how long the review period lasts, and how a response may be submitted.
Under the Policy on Discrimination, Harassment, and Sexual Misconduct, after the investigator has interviewed the parties and relevant witnesses and gathered the relevant evidence, the investigator prepares a preliminary investigative report. The preliminary report summarizes relevant information and evidence gathered during the investigation. It does not contain findings about whether University policy was violated. Both parties have an opportunity to review the preliminary report and submit a written response.
Under the Policy on Discrimination, Harassment, and Sexual Misconduct, a party may use the response to:
- identify information they believe is inaccurate or incomplete;
- comment on information in the report;
- provide additional relevant documents or information;
- identify additional witnesses;
- ask the investigator to take additional investigative steps; and
- suggest relevant questions for a party or witness.
The response may be up to 20 pages and ordinarily must be submitted within 10 business days after the preliminary report is made available. OCR may adjust these requirements or grant an extension for good cause as permitted by the policy.
The investigator reviews the parties’ responses and determines whether additional investigation is needed.
That could include obtaining documents, conducting follow-up interviews, interviewing additional witnesses, or asking additional questions.
If significant new information requires further investigation under the Policy on Discrimination, Harassment, and Sexual Misconduct, the investigator may issue a second preliminary investigative report and provide another opportunity for the parties to respond.
No. You may not share the report or post it. You will be provided view only access to the investigative materials, which are provided for purposes of the University’s complaint resolution process and should be treated as private. These restrictions do not prevent a party from obtaining appropriate assistance during the process, including assistance from an advisor or attorney, consistent with the applicable policy and any required release.
Findings and Next Steps
Northwestern uses the preponderance of the evidence standard. In plain language, this means deciding whether the evidence shows that it is more likely than not that the alleged policy violation occurred. This is different from the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard used in criminal cases.
That depends on which policy applies.
Under the Policy on Discrimination, Harassment, and Sexual Misconduct, the investigator makes findings in the final investigative report using the preponderance of the evidence standard. The report explains the evidence considered, the investigator’s analysis, and the rationale for each finding.
Under the Title IX policy, the investigator gathers and organizes the evidence but does not decide whether the respondent is responsible for Title IX Sexual Harassment. The Title IX Decision Maker makes that determination following a Title IX hearing.
Under the Policy on Discrimination, Harassment, and Sexual Misconduct, the investigator prepares a final investigative report after considering the parties’ responses to the preliminary report and completing any additional investigation.
The complainant and respondent are notified of the outcome and provided access to the final investigative report. If there is more than one alleged policy violation, a separate finding is made for each potential policy violation.
If there is no finding of a policy violation, the parties receive information about their appeal rights.
If a violation is found, the matter proceeds to the appropriate University process for determining sanctions and remedies. The person or office responsible for sanctions depends on whether the respondent is a student, staff member, faculty member, or other community member.
Yes. Under the Policy on Discrimination, Harassment, and Sexual Misconduct, a respondent may notify OCR in writing that they accept responsibility for prohibited conduct before the investigation concludes.
If responsibility is accepted for all allegations, a complete investigation may no longer be necessary. If responsibility is accepted for only some allegations, OCR will determine how to proceed with the remaining allegations.
The procedures that apply in a Title IX matter are different, so a respondent who is considering accepting responsibility should speak with OCR about the available options.
A complainant may ask OCR to withdraw a complaint or particular allegations. A request to withdraw does not necessarily mean that the investigation will automatically end. OCR will determine whether the matter can be closed or whether the University needs to continue addressing some or all of the allegations.
Yes. In circumstances identified in the applicable policy, OCR may dismiss a complaint or particular allegations even after an investigation has begun.
For example, dismissal may be appropriate if the University cannot identify the respondent after reasonable efforts, the respondent is no longer affiliated with Northwestern, the complainant withdraws allegations and the remaining allegations would not constitute prohibited conduct, or the alleged conduct would not violate the applicable policy even if it occurred as alleged.
The specific dismissal rules differ between the two policies. When a complaint or allegation is dismissed, OCR will provide the notice required by the applicable policy and information about the available appeal rights.
Other Common Questions
Raise the concern with OCR as soon as possible. Investigators and other decision-makers may not serve in a case in which they have a material conflict of interest or material bias. You should notify OCR of a potential conflict of interest within two business days of receiving the Notice of Investigation or of learning the potential conflict of interest.
Everyone participating in an investigation is expected to provide truthful information. Knowingly or intentionally providing false information may violate University policy and may result in disciplinary action.
However, an allegation that is not substantiated is not, by itself, evidence that someone made a false report. A good-faith report does not become a false report simply because there is not enough evidence to establish a policy violation.
Ask your OCR contact. You can contact the Intake, Support and Informal Resolution Specialist or the Civil Rights and Title IX Compliance Specialist assigned to the investigation.
Participants are not expected to understand every part of the process on their own. OCR can explain procedural steps, deadlines, the role of an advisor, how to submit information, how to request supportive measures, and other procedural questions.
Asking a question about the process does not affect how the evidence or allegations will be evaluated.
Let OCR know if there is something about the process that is making participation difficult.
OCR can discuss available supportive measures, accessibility options, and other resources. Participants may also seek support from confidential resources, health care providers, counselors, advisors, attorneys, family members, or other appropriate sources of support.
Requesting support does not affect how OCR evaluates the evidence.