Frequently Asked Hearing Questions
This page provides an overview of the Title IX hearing process at Northwestern University, including how to prepare, what to expect during the hearing, the responsibilities of participants and the steps involved in reaching and appealing a determination.
The Basics of a Hearing
A Title IX hearing is the adjudication stage of the University complaint resolution process. A neutral Decision Maker reviews the investigative record, hears live testimony and advisor questioning, rules on relevance and determines whether the Policy on Title IX Sexual Harassment (Title IX Policy) was violated using the preponderance of the evidence standard. A Title IX hearing is an administrative process and not a legal proceeding.
The Decision Maker is a trained, neutral individual appointed by the Office of Civil Rights and Title IX Compliance (OCR) to facilitate the hearing, decide relevance and admissibility issues, evaluate the evidence and issue the written determination. The parties are notified of the Decision Maker’s identity with the Notice of Hearing.
The Decision Maker uses the preponderance of the evidence standard. This asks whether it is more likely than not that a policy violation occurred.
The hearing generally includes the parties (e.g., Complainant and Respondent), their advisors, the Decision Maker, the Title IX Coordinator or designee and other necessary University personnel. Upon request, parties may also have a support person available to them in a breakout room. However, support persons may not be present in the live hearing room. Witnesses are generally only permitted to be present in the live hearing room when they are providing testimony. The Decision Maker may address case-specific attendance questions.
Hearing Preparation
The OCR staff member serving as the Hearing Coordinator will send the parties and their advisors the Notice of Hearing and the Investigative Report, with view-only access to Investigative Report and Exhibits. The Notice of Hearing will include:
- the deadline to respond to the Investigative Report;
- the scheduled date and time for the pre-hearing conference and Zoom link;
- the scheduled date and time for the hearing and Zoom link;
- information about the Decision Maker; and
- instructions on information to include with the response to the Investigative Report.
The pre-hearing conference is a meeting held before the hearing. The pre-hearing conference is held via Zoom. Both parties and their advisors may attend. The pre-hearing conference is typically scheduled for one hour. It addresses the process, expectations and structure for the hearing, proposed witnesses, logistics and accommodations. It does not involve questioning the parties about the alleged conduct.
Review the Investigative Report, exhibits, and any response you submitted. Confirm your advisor and proposed witnesses with the Hearing Coordinator. Plan to participate from a private location where no one else can see or hear the pre-hearing conference. If you do not have a private location to participate from, notify OCR and they will access with locating a private space for you on campus.
Contact the Hearing Coordinator as early as possible to request a disability-related accommodation, language access or another accessibility support. The office will address the request through the appropriate University process.
Notify the Hearing Coordinator immediately and explain the conflict. The Hearing Coordinator will provide potential options to address unavoidable conflicts, including, but not limited to, assisting to obtain an excused absence from work or class. Do not assume the hearing has been rescheduled unless you receive written confirmation from OCR with a new date and time for the hearing. Deadlines and hearing dates may be modified for good cause at the University’s discretion.
Yes. Parties may consider engaging in Alternative Resolution (AR) even after the hearing has been scheduled. Alternative Resolution is voluntary, and the University will not require parties to engage in AR. If a party is interested in Alternative Resolution, they should inform their Hearing Coordinator. OCR will determine if the matter is appropriate for AR, and if so, OCR will contact the other party to understand whether they are also interested in AR. If both parties agree to engage in the AR process, the Decision Maker will be informed and the hearing will be paused while parties engage in the AR process. If the parties are successful in reaching an agreement, the hearing will be canceled. If parties are unable to reach any resolution through AR, the hearing will continue. Please note, in some situations the hearing may need to be rescheduled to allow for parties to fully engage in the AR process.
Hearing Participation
Yes. Each party may have one advisor of their choice. The advisor may be an attorney, but does not have to be. At the hearing, the advisor conducts questioning on the party’s behalf.
If a party does not have an advisor present at the hearing, OCR will provide an advisor, without fee or charge, to conduct questioning on that party’s behalf. OCR selects the advisor. Contact the Hearing Coordinator in advance of the hearing if you need an University-appointed hearing advisor.
Parties will typically have two meetings with their University-appointed advisor, an introduction meeting and a hearing preparation meeting. The University-appointed hearing advisor may assist parties throughout the hearing process, including:
- Engaging in discussions around the party’s response to the Investigative Report;
- Reviewing a party’s response to the Investigative Report and providing feedback;
- Assisting parties in drafting questions to be asked during the hearing of the other party and witnesses;
- Reviewing a party’s closing statement and providing feedback;
- Reviewing a party’s impact/mitigation statement and providing feedback; and
- Engaging in a debrief meeting with the parties to understand the determination letter.
Except for conducting cross-examination questioning during the hearing, the advisor generally serves in a supporting role and does not communicate or submit information on the party’s behalf. Parties should communicate directly with and submit requested information directly to the Hearing Coordinator, unless instructed otherwise.
Parties are permitted to have one support person accompany them during the hearing. The support person will not be permitted to observe the live hearing, but will be placed in the party’s breakout room. The support person is present to provide additional support to the party.
The parties and the Decision Maker may identify witnesses that they would like to have present at the hearing. The Decision Maker will determine which witnesses will be requested for the hearing. An OCR staff member will send attendance notices and coordinate scheduling with witnesses. A witness should promptly report any material and unavoidable conflict.
No. Participation is voluntary. Parties are not required to attend or participate in the hearing. If a party or witness does not attend or declines to answer a question, the Decision Maker may rely on relevant evidence otherwise available, such as evidence gathered during the investigation. The Decision Maker may not draw an adverse inference solely from a person’s absence or refusal to answer.
Yes. The hearing may proceed using the relevant evidence available through the investigation and hearing process.
What to Expect During the Hearing
The hearing is conducted virtually, via Zoom. The Hearing Coordinator will provide the parties and their advisors with the link in the Notice of Hearing.
Yes, parties and their advisors must have their cameras on for the duration of the hearing. Parties must be able to see and hear the person answering questions. If a party does not want to see the other party during the hearing, they may use the Zoom feature to pin their screen on the Decision Maker. Zoom provides instructions on how to pin a video.
The Decision Maker may question parties and witnesses. After the Decision Maker’s questions, each party’s advisor may ask the other party and witnesses relevant questions and follow-up questions, including questions concerning credibility. The Decision Maker must decide on relevancy before a question is answered. The parties do not question each other or witnesses directly.
Before a party or witness answers a question, the Decision Maker determines whether the question is relevant. The Decision Maker explains a decision to exclude a question as not relevant. Duplicative or repetitive questions may be excluded.
A party’s medical records may not be accessed, considered, disclosed, or used without voluntary written consent from the party whose records they are. In addition, information or records protected from disclosure by any legally protected privilege, such as attorney-client privilege, may not be obtained without the party’s voluntary written consent. Further, questions about a Complainant’s sexual predisposition or prior sexual behavior are generally not relevant, subject to the limited exceptions stated in the policy.
The Decision Maker is responsible for maintaining decorum during the hearing. A party or advisor who materially and repeatedly violates hearing rules in a materially disruptive way may have participation limited or be barred from further participation, at the Decision Maker’s discretion.
Yes. Throughout the hearing, the Decision Maker will provide regular breaks. In addition, any party may request a break. Private breakout rooms will be available for each party and advisor.
Yes. An audio recording and transcript are made of the live hearing. The transcript is available to the parties for inspection and review upon request.
Post Hearing
After the hearing, the parties have five business days to submit a written statement (not to exceed five pages).
- The Complainant may submit a written statement describing the impact of the conduct on the Complainant, including preferred sanctions and description of any other information Complainant believes to be relevant to the issue of remedies and sanctions.
- The Respondent may submit a written statement explaining any factors that the Respondent believes should mitigate or otherwise be considered in determining the sanctions and any other information Respondent believes relevant to the issue of remedies and sanctions.
Parties may submit the statements to the Title IX Coordinator at OCR@northwestern.edu. Statements will only be shared with the Decision Maker and appropriate individuals in determining sanctions and remedies if there is a finding of a policy violation.
After the hearing, the Decision Maker objectively evaluates all relevant evidence collected during the investigation and testimony and non-testimony evidence gathered during the hearing, including inculpatory and exculpatory evidence. The Decision Maker may conduct credibility assessment as needed of parties and witnesses. The Decision Maker will resolve disputed facts using a preponderance of the evidence standard and reach a determination whether the facts that are supported by a preponderance constitute a policy violation.
The written determination includes:
- the allegations,
- a summary of procedural steps,
- findings of fact that support the determination,
- conclusions regarding the application of the Title IX Policy to the facts,
- the result and rationale for each allegation,
- any disciplinary sanctions, if imposed,
- whether remedies will be provided and
- an explanation of the appeal procedures and permissible bases.
The parties receive the written determination simultaneously after the Decision Maker reaches a determination and completes any required consultation regarding sanctions. The Hearing Coordinator will provide parties with advanced notice the day before the written determination will be issued.
If the Decision Maker finds a policy violation, the Decision Maker consults with the appropriate University personnel regarding sanctions.
- For student respondents, the Decision Maker will consult with the University Hearing and Appeals System (UHAS) Sanctioning Panel.
- For staff Respondents, the Decision Maker will consult with the appropriate Human Resources Business Partner and the Respondent’s supervisor.
- For faculty Respondents, the Decision Maker will consult with the Respondent’s department chair, Dean, and the Associate Provost for Faculty Affairs, and as appropriate, a faculty sanctioning panel in accordance with the Faculty Handbook.
The Title IX Coordinator in consultation with the appropriate individuals determine whether ongoing supportive measures or other remedies will be provided to the Complainant.
Yes. Either party may appeal a dismissal or determination on the limited grounds stated in the policy:
- Procedural irregularity that affected the outcome of the matter;
- New evidence that was not reasonably available at the time the determination regarding responsibility or dismissal was made, that could affect the outcome of the matter;
- The Title IX Coordinator, investigator(s), or Decision Maker(s) had a conflict of interest or bias for or against Complainants or Respondents generally or the individual Complainant or Respondent that affected the outcome of the matter; or
- The sanction is disproportionate with the violation.
A party must file an appeal within 10 business days of the date the hearing determination is issued. If an appeal is filed, the other party is notified and has 10 business days to submit a written response.
The determination becomes final when the appeal reviewer issues the written appeal decision, if an appeal is filed or when the appeal deadline passes without a timely appeal.
Privacy, Support and Questions
The University treats reports and investigations as private matters and limits the hearing to authorized participants. Information may be shared when necessary to carry out the University’s Title IX obligations, provide supportive measures, conduct the process or comply with law.
Yes. The policy prohibits retaliation against anyone for engaging in a protected activity, such as filing a Title IX report and/or participating in the Title IX process. If you believe you have been subjected to retaliation for your participation in the Title IX process, please contact OCR at OCR@northwestern.edu or file a report with OCR at www.northwestern.edu/report
Yes. Supportive measures and resources remain available throughout the Title IX process and can continue after it concludes. Contact OCR if your needs change or if you would like to discuss available options.
Contact the Hearing Coordinator identified in your case communications. General questions may be directed to the Office of Civil Rights and Title IX Compliance at ocr@northwestern.edu.