Optimizing Donor Kidney Distribution in the United States
Four hundred lives a year could be saved by donor kidney distribution modelFebruary 14, 2014 | by Megan Fellman
EVANSTON, Ill. --- Northwestern University’s Sanjay Mehrotra has developed an innovative model that could help ease kidney distribution inequities among regions in the U.S. and ultimately help save hundreds of lives. His mathematical model, which takes into account a number of different factors, simulates and optimizes donor kidney distribution.
Mehrotra discussed his research in a presentation titled “Addressing Allocation Inefficiencies and Geographic Disparities” at the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) annual meeting in Chicago. His presentation was part of a Feb. 14 symposium titled ”Transplant Organ Shortage: Informing National Policies Using Management Sciences.” Mehrotra also participated in a press briefing the same day.
In addition to Mehrotra, two other Northwestern professors discussed issues related to organ shortage during both the symposium and press briefing.
Michael Abecassis, M.D., chief of the division of organ transplantation and founding director of the Comprehensive Transplant Center at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, offered a brief overview of the current issues facing organ allocation.
John Friedewald, M.D., associate professor in medicine and surgery at Feinberg and director of clinical research at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine Comprehensive Transplant Center and transplant nephrologist at Northwestern Memorial Hospital, spoke about policy changes in kidney allocation that were developed during his recent term as chair of the United Network for Organ Sharing Kidney Transplantation Committee.
Nearly 100,000 people in the United States are waiting for kidney transplants, but only 17,000 kidneys are available annually from both living and deceased donors. There are major regional inequalities in access to organs because of supply and demand disparities among different areas of the country. A person in one state might get a kidney within a year, while someone in another state might wait up to four years. As a consequence, nearly 5,000 people die each year waiting for a kidney transplant.
Logistically, organ allocation is a difficult problem. The country is divided into 11 transplant regions (which are themselves divided into 58 donor service areas). Because patients must provide biological samples to their specific transplant center beforehand, and because kidney donations must happen within 24 hours of harvesting, most kidneys are distributed within the same geographic zone in which they are donated. But regions vary in how many kidneys they receive a year, and centers differ in the quality of kidneys they accept for transplant.
Mehrotra, a professor of industrial engineering and management sciences at Northwestern’s McCormick School of Engineering and Applied Science, provides a solution by combining each of these factors into a model that can optimize distribution.
His model identifies areas for policy changes, including encouraging more sharing within states, encouraging transplant centers with long wait times to transplant lower-quality kidneys and encouraging insurance companies to weigh the cost-benefit analysis of dialysis versus transplanting lower-quality kidneys.