Dennis Chong
From the cover
copy of Rational Lives: Norms and Values in Politics and Society
(University of Chicago Press, 2000).
Rational Lives is a study of value formation
and change, group identification, and conflict over social norms
and lifestyles. Most scholars who study value conflicts have resisted
rational choice approaches to the subject on the grounds that
social conflict between groups is best explained by expressive
motives and other nonrational factors. In contrast to this view,
Dennis Chong shows that a single model that combines economic
and sociological mechanisms can explain how people make decisions
across both cultural and economic realms. He argues that the investments
people make in the norms and values of their communities reflect
the influence of their psychological dispositions, as well as
the social and material costs and benefits of the options they
face.
Chong brings these issues to life by examining a variety of historical
and contemporary political conflicts over social norms. In one
example, he explores what happens when residents of a Texas community
must decide if they are willing to compromise their moral values
in exchange for a new business development that will create jobs
and fuel the local economy. He also shows how a new norm of racial
equality diffused in the South following World War II as people
modified their attitudes and behavior when it became too costly
for them to continue their past practices. Through these and other
cases, Chong demonstrates that our understanding of social conflict
must recognize that norms have instrumental power and that people
have an emotional attachment to their culture.
Rational Lives yields numerous insights into how people
are mobilized around common identities and values to defend their
way of life. Most significantly, the book offers a provocative
explanation of how ingrained norms and values can change over
time in spite of the myriad forces working to maintain the status
quo.
"Rational Lives is an outstanding contribution
to the rational choice debate, one that both its critics and especially
its more gung-ho defenders should read carefully." -- Michael
Taylor, University of Washington
"Dennis Chong's new book is full of hard thinking and interesting
case studies. It will interest all social scientists concerned
with the debate between rational choice theory and cultural explanations.
Going beyond the tired polemics on both sides, he constructs a
new interpretation of human behavior in which culture and individual
rationality both matter. In Chong's argument, people take symbols
and other cultural signs seriously even when there is no instrumentally
rational reason to do so. Yet culture is not static: it responds
over time in a quasi-Bayesian manner. Many of the disputes between
rational choice and their opponents are thus resolved, leaving
neither side a complete victor. The synthesis is a more comprehensive
and powerful explanatory framework than either side could have
produced, and Chong's creativity should influence subsequent interpretations
of our social life in fundamental ways." -- Christopher H.
Achen, University of Michigan